"We must remember that cultures do not get shaped in isolation. Every culture is partially shaped by the other cultures it encounters and what it imbibes from them, and how it responds to the initially unfamiliar. We in our histories have tended to focus on just one identity, but in effect we have to look at migrations, contacts, interactions-both complementary and hostile. We have to be ready to concede where another may have helped shape us, even if we wish that this did not happen. We have to be willing to grant that there was often a mutually beneficial exchange of ideas," says Dr. Romila Thapar (p. 180), in this succinct, engaging conversation with writer Namit Aurora.
The book deals with so many of the important and controversial issues being debated to day in the public sphere about Indian's history. This simple paragraph is as good a summary of the intelligent and sophisticated approach to history that is a hallmark of Dr. Thapar's career. While the ancient Indus civilization is not mentioned much, it is also provides a fine lens through which we should try and understand that civilization: not merely as a monolithic, solely indigenous civilization or culture ("one identity'), but a multi-faceted, changing, complex one with pieces in conversation with another just like cultures today. And one that developed in relationship both to other cultures around it (to the west, east and north), and the various cultures (Amri, Kulli, Ahar Banas, etc.) within and next to it. Much harder to fathom than simplifications.
So many controversies are dealt with calmly in the back and forth format, from India-Aryan migration, to Buddhist, Muslim and other phases, being a "Marxist historian," and the way that British colonial history infects modern Indian history and politics all too much. Having grown of age during this transition from colonial rule, Dr. Thapar is well able to articulate a continuing malady. Arora's questions (see his recommended video Indians - A Brief History of a Civilization: Ep 1 - The Harappans) and explanations are those of a well-informed interlocutor.
Two things stand out about the book.
One is the advice Romila Thapar gives to students of the historical method - go read Agatha Christie's Death on the Nile. The whole book is also sprinkled with her answers that ask for more information and research into a unfilled area of history, where it is easily to speculate but the evidence is thin, which is a lot of the subcontinent's history the further back you go. Incidentally, Agatha Christie was married to an archaeologist, and went to many digs, contributed and took careful notes in Mesopotamia for example, and the Hercule Poirot mystery referenced takes place in the shadow of the pyramids.
The second, pertinent to readers of this website, is the role of the public historian. The authors make a good case for the need for this role, people who try to bring the often complex world of scholarship in, say, ancient Indian archaeology or linguistics, in a reasonable way to a wider audience even if sometimes making mistakes: Harappa.com or Disha Ahluwalia for example in the case of the ancient Indus versus those who just make things up. The other strand that seems to emerge is that public historians should also try to bring an interdisciplinary point-of-view to the discussion, often lacking in the increasingly specialized area of scholarship – of which there is far too little on the ancient Indus or ancient history in general, unless "lucky" enough to have Alexander the Great march through, like in 327-325 BCE.
Dr. Thapar puts this development in modern historiography after Partition: "The second change is the turn to using an interdisciplinary approach. Relevant data is no longer limited to historical sources but also includes patterns of analysis and models that come from disciplines with proximities to history, such as archaeology, linguistics, genetics, sociology, economic history, ecology and the history of religion. This is often introduced by including history as one of many disciplines in the social sciences that inform each other.
"These two changes are what really separate Indology from the modern understanding of history. Indology refers to the colonial era enterprise that mainly focused on studying Indian texts, languages and religions and tended to privilege scriptures, epics and elite literature. Today's discipline of history goes far beyond the narrow scope of Indology through its range of sources, questions, tools, methods, analysis, interdisciplinary approaches and so on," (p. 50).
An easy read which makes you smarter about history.
- Omar Khan, Nov. 2026.
Our interview with Dr. Thapar was made in Delhi in 2026.